Audit your goal system

Creates a ranked list of weaknesses in how your company sets, scores and updates goals, with evidence from your own files and what to change first.

This skill audits how a company sets, scores and updates goals, working from its own files: goal or KPI trackers, progress updates, review comments, and meeting notes. It reconstructs how the system actually works, checks it against 15 lenses, ranks the weaknesses with evidence, and says what to change first. It critiques the system, not the people whose goals are in the files.

When to use it

  • Almost everyone ends the year at 100% and the score tells you nothing.
  • Goals are set in January and never touched again.
  • Leadership asks whether goals are driving results and you have no answer.
  • You're about to tie goals to reviews or bonuses and want to know whether the scores can carry that.
  • You're a consultant or vendor preparing for a conversation with a client about their goals.

What you get

A reply in chat, or a document if you ask, with six parts:

  • Scope: what was read, whose goals, the snapshot date, and what's missing.
  • How the system works: structure, what a goal is in practice, how scoring rolls up, cadence, and what the score is used for.
  • Weaknesses: ranked by impact, each a one-line claim followed by the evidence. The top five in full, the rest in one line each.
  • What to change: in order, first and later.
  • Open questions: only what the files leave open.
  • Safe to raise / handle with care: which findings are about process and which touch a person's own goals or their manager's decisions.

How it works

  1. It reads every file fully. For spreadsheets it reads formulas as well as values: =3/7 shows how progress is counted, and the value alone doesn't. It notes the snapshot date, because lateness can only be judged against it.
  2. It describes the system as it is. Before criticising anything, it reconstructs the structure, scoring and cadence, and recomputes the overall score itself, showing the arithmetic.
  3. It checks 15 lenses. Among them: whether goals state a result or an activity; what says a 100% was done well; whether the score reacts to lateness; stale goals; how the percentage is produced; whether weights follow importance; goals blocked by someone else; score distribution; and whether review comments agree with goal scores. Every finding cites the row, goal name or quote. A lens with no evidence gets "no evidence in the files".
  4. It recommends what fits. Each recommendation ties to a finding and is sized to the company. A company running goals in one spreadsheet won't absorb quarterly re-planning for everyone in one step, so it says what to change first and what can wait.

What it never does. It doesn't invent numbers, benchmarks or statistics. It doesn't trust the sheet's total. It doesn't claim what a specific goals tool can do unless that's documented. If only one person's or one department's goals are available, it says so at the top and treats findings as hypotheses. On pay, it notes the incentives the link creates but gives no payout formulas or amounts: compensation design needs your finance or compensation owner.

How to run it

Install the Effy AI plugin for Claude or ChatGPT. One install adds every Effy AI skill, this one included. Then connect the tools you want the skill to read from, such as email, calendar, your drive or your meeting notetaker, and ask for what you need in plain words: the assistant picks the right skill.

Before you start: gather goal or KPI trackers (several versions if they exist), review forms and comments, and any notes on how the process works.

  1. Ask, for example: "Effy, audit our goal system."
  2. Attach the files and say whether you're auditing your own company or a client's.
  3. Read the audit and decide what to raise, and with whom.

Click. Try. Use.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.